Bush’s Individual Account Proposal: Rhetoric Versus Reality

George W. Bush won plaudits during the recent election campaign for “starting a conversation” on Social Security. Unfortunately, the discussion thus far has been long on misleading rhetoric and short on hard facts. Bush suggests radically changing Social Security, transforming it from a social insurance program into an investment scheme. Under his proposal, a portion of workers’ contributions would be diverted out of the Social Security system and into individual investment accounts. Bush suggests that such a seismic shift in policy is called for because the current system is hurtling toward insolvency. Moreover, he asserts that under a partially privatized system workers would receive higher benefits. These statements are simply wrong:

  • Social Security finances are sound. The “crisis” had been invented.
  • Bush and other proponents of privatization greatly understate the costs of their proposed new system.
  • Not only will many workers across the spectrum face a severe loss of income under Bush’s radically transformed system, but the disabled, lower-income earners, and most women will face the most severe cuts.
  • Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More To Read

February 15, 2019

Low Pay for Early Childhood Educators Hits Hispanics Harder

Early childhood educators make much less than K-12 teachers, and are twice as likely to be Hispanic

February 11, 2019

Countdown to Conception

How to Get the Most Buck for Your Bang with Paid Leave

February 7, 2019

Hiring Based on Previous Salary Perpetuates Inequality

HB 1696 and SB 5090 prohibit screening job applicants based on income history